APPENDIX
A HISTORICAL SKETCH OF EUROPEAN MYSTICISM FROM
THE BEGINNING OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA TO THE DEATH OF BLAKE
I
F we try to represent the course of Mysticism in Europe during the
Christian period by the common device of a chronological curve, showing by its
rises and falls as it passes across the centuries the absence or preponderance
in any given epoch of mystics and mystical thought, we shall find that the
great periods of mystical activity tend to correspond with the great periods of
artistic, material, and intellectual civilization. As a rule, they come
immediately after, and seem to complete such periods: those outbursts of
vitality in which man makes fresh conquests over his universe apparently
producing, as their last stage, a type of heroic character which extends these
victories to the spiritual sphere. When science, politics, literature, and the
arts--the domination of nature and the ordering of life--have risen to their
height and produced their greatest works, the mystic comes to the front;
snatches the torch, and carries it on. It is almost as if he were humanity's
finest flower; the product at which each great creative period of the race had
aimed. Thus the thirteenth century expressed to
perfection the medieval ideal in religion, art, philosophy, and public life. It
built the Gothic cathedrals, put the finishing touch to the system of chivalry,
and nourished the scholastic philosophers. It has many saints, but not very
many mystics; though they increase in number as the century draws on. The
fourteenth century is filled by great contemplatives; who lifted this wave of
activity to spiritual levels, and brought the intellectual vigour, the romance
and passion of the mediaeval temperament, to bear upon the deepest mysteries of
the transcendental life. Again, the sixteenth century, that period of abounding
vitality which left no corner of existence unexplored, which produced the
Renaissance and the Humanists and remade the mediaeval world, had hardly
reached its full development before the great procession of the
post-Renaissance mystics, with St. Teresa at their head, began. If life,
then--the great and restless life of the race--be described under the trite
metaphor of a billowy sea, each great wave as it rises from the deep bears the
mystic type upon its crest.
Our curve will therefore follow close behind that
other curve which represents the intellectual life of humanity. Its course will
be studded and defined for us by the names of the great mystics; the possessors
of spiritual genius, the pathfinders to the country of the soul. These starry
names are significant not only in themselves but also as links in the chain of
manes growing spiritual history. They are not isolated phenomena,
but are related to one another. Each receives something from his predecessors:
each by his personal adventures enriches it, and hands it on to the future. As
we go on, we notice more and more this cumulative power of the past. Each
mystic, original though he be, yet owes much to the inherited acquirement of
his spiritual ancestors. These ancestors form his tradition, are the classic
examples on which his education is based; and from them he takes the language
which they have sought out and constructed as a means of telling their
adventures to the world. It is by their help too, very often, that he
elucidates for himself the meaning of the dim perceptions of his amazed soul.
From his own experiences he adds to this store; and hands on an enriched
tradition of the transcendental life to the next spiritual genius evolved by
the race. Hence the names of the great mystics are connected by a thread; and
it becomes possible to treat them as subjects of history rather than of
biography.
I have said that this thread forms a curve,
following the fluctuations of the intellectual life of the race. At its highest
points, the names of the mystics are clustered most thickly, at its descents
they become fewer and fewer, at the lowest points they die away. Between the
first century A.D. and the nineteenth, this curve exhibits three great waves of
mystical activity besides many minor fluctuations. They correspond with the
close of the Classical, the Mediaeval, and the Renaissance periods in history:
reaching their highest points in the third, fourteenth, and seventeenth
centuries. In one respect, however, the mystic curve diverges from the
historical one. It rises to its highest point in the fourteenth century, and
does not again approach the level it there attains; for the mediaeval period
was more favourable to the development of mysticism than any subsequent epoch
has been. The fourteenth century is as much the classic moment for the
spiritual history of our race as the thirteenth is for the history of Gothic,
or the fifteenth for that of Italian art.
The names upon our curve, especially during the
first ten centuries of the Christian era, are often separated by long periods
of time. This, of course, does not necessarily mean that these centuries
produced few mystics: merely that few documents relating to them have survived.
We have now no means of knowing, for instance, the amount of true mysticism
which may have existed amongst the initiates of the Greek or Egyptian
Mysteries; how many advanced but inarticulate contemplatives there were amongst
the Alexandrian Neo-platonists, amongst the pre-Christian communities of
contemplatives described by Philo, the deeply mystical Alexandrian Jew
(20 B.C.-A.D. 40), or the innumerable Gnostic sects which replaced in the early
Christian world the Orphic and Dionysiac mystery-cults of Greece and Italy.
Much real mystical inspiration there must have been, for we know that from
these centres of life came many of the doctrines best loved by later mystics:
that the Neoplatonists gave them the concepts of Pure Being and the One, that
the New Birth and the Spiritual Marriage were foreshadowed in the Mysteries,
that Philo anticipated the theology of the Fourth Gospel.
As we stand at the beginning of the Christian
period we see three great sources whence its mystical tradition might have been
derived. These sources are Greek, Oriental, and Christian--i.e.,
primitive Apostolic--doctrine or thought. As a matter of fact all contributed
their share: but where Christianity gave the new vital impulse to
transcendence, Greek and Oriental thought provided the principal forms in which
it was expressed. The Christian religion, by its very nature, had a profoundly
mystical side. Putting the personality of its Founder outside the limits of the
present discussion, St. Paul and the author of the Fourth Gospel are
obvious instances of mystics of the first rank amongst its earliest
missionaries. Much of the inner history of primitive Christianity still remains
unknown to us, but in what has been already made out we find numerous, if
scattered, indications that the mystic life was indigenous in the Church and
the natural mystic had little need to look for inspiration outside the limits
of his creed. Not only the epistles of St. Paul and the Johannine writings, but
also the earliest liturgic fragments which we possess, and such primitive
religious poetry as the "Odes of Solomon" and the "Hymn of Jesus," show how
congenial was mystical expression to the mind of the Church how easily that
Church could absorb and transmute the mystic elements of Essene, Orphic, and
Neoplatonic thought.
Towards the end of the second century this
tendency received brilliant literary expression at the hands of Clement of
Alexandria (c. 160-220)--who first adapted the language of the pagan
Mysteries to the Christian theory of the spiritual life--and his great pupil
Origen (c. 183-253). Nevertheless, the first person after St. Paul of
whom it can now be decisively stated that he was a practical mystic of the
first rank, and in whose writings the central mystic doctrine of union with God
is found, is a pagan. That person is Plotinus, the great Neoplatonic
philosopher of Alexandria (A.D. 205-c. 270). His mysticism owes nothing to the
Christian religion, which is never mentioned in his works. Intellectually it is
based on the Platonic philosophy, and also shows the influence of the
Mysteries, and perhaps certain of the Oriental cults and philosophies which ran
riot in Alexandria in the third century. Ostensibly a metaphysician, however,
Plotinus possessed transcendental genius of a high order, and was consumed by a
burning passion for the Absolute: and the importance of his work lies in the
degree in which his intellectual constructions are made the vehicle of mystical
experience. His disciple Porphyry has left it on record that on four occasions
he saw his master rapt to ecstatic union with "the One."
The Neoplatonism of which Plotinus was the
greatest exponent became the medium in which much of the mysticism--both
Christian and pagan--of the first six centuries was expressed. But since
mysticism is a way of life--an experience of Reality, not a philosophic account
of Reality--Neoplatonism, and the mysticism which used its language, must not
be identified with one another. Porphyry (233-304) the favourite pupil
of Plotinus seems to have inherited something of his master's mysticism, but
Neoplatonism as a whole was a confused, semi-religious philosophy, containing
many inconsistent elements. Appearing when the wreck of paganism
was complete, but before Christianity had conquered the educated world, it made
a strong appeal to the spiritually minded; and also to those who hankered after
the mysterious and the occult. It taught the illusory nature of all temporal
things, and in the violence of its idealism outdid its master Plato. It also
taught the existence of an Absolute God, the "Unconditioned One," who might be
known in ecstasy and contemplation; and here it made a direct appeal to the
mystical instincts of men. Those natural mystics who lived in the time of its
greatest popularity found in it therefore a ready means of expressing their own
intuitions of reality. Hence the early mysticism of Europe, both Christian and
pagan, has come down to us in a Neoplatonic dress; and speaks the tongue of
Alexandria rather than that of Jerusalem, Athens, or Rome.
The influence of Plotinus upon later Christian
mysticism was enormous though indirect. During the patristic period all that
was best in the spirit of Neoplatonism flowed into the veins of the Church.
St. Augustine (A.D. 354-430) and Dionysius the Areopagite
(writing between 475 and 525) are amongst his spiritual children; and it is
mainly through them that his doctrine reached the mediaeval world.
Proclus (412-c. 490), the last of the pagan philosophers, also derives
from his teaching. Through these three there is hardly one in the long tale of
the European contemplatives whom his powerful spirit has failed to reach.
The mysticism of St. Augustine is partly obscured
for us by the wealth of his intellectual and practical life: yet no one can
read the "Confessions" without being struck by the intensity and actuality of
his spiritual experience, and the characteristically mystical formula under
which he apprehended Reality. It is clear that when he composed this work he
was already an advanced contemplative. The immense intellectual activities by
which he is best remembered were fed by the solitary adventures of his soul. No
merely literary genius could have produced the wonderful chapters in the
seventh and eighth books, or the innumerable detached passages in which his
passion for the Absolute breaks out. Later mystics, recognizing this fact,
constantly appeal to his authority, and his influence ranks next to that of the
Bible in the formation of the mediaeval school.
Second only to that of St. Augustine was the
influence exercised by the strange and nameless writer who chose to ascribe his
works to Dionysius the Areopagite, the friend of St. Paul, and to address his
letters upon mysticism to Paul's fellow-worker, Timothy. The pseudo-Dionysius
was probably a Syrian monk. The patristic quotations detected in his work prove
that he cannot have written before A.D. 475; it is most likely that he
flourished in the early part of the sixth century. His chief works are the
treatises on the Angelic Hierarchies and on the Names of God, and a short but
priceless tract on mystical theology. From the ninth century to the seventeenth
these writings nourished the most spiritual intuitions of men, and possessed an
authority which it is now hard to realize. Medieval mysticism is soaked in
Dionysian conceptions. Particularly in the fourteenth century, the golden age of mystical literature, the phrase "Dionysius saith" is of
continual recurrence: and has for those who use it much the same weight as
quotations from the Bible or the great fathers of the Church.
The importance of Dionysius lies in the fact that
he was the first and for a long time the only, Christian writer who attempted
to describe frankly and accurately the workings of the mystical consciousness,
and the nature of its ecstatic attainment of God. So well did he do h s work
that later contemplatives, reading him, found their most sublime experiences
reflected and partly explained. Hence in describing those experiences, they
adopted his language and metaphors; which afterwards became the classic terms
of contemplative science. To him Christian literature owes the paradoxical
concept of the Absolute Godhead as the "Divine Dark," the Unconditioned, "the
negation of all that is"--i.e., of all that the surface
consciousness perceives--and of the soul's attainment of the Absolute as a
"divine ignorance," a way of negation. This idea is common to Greek and Indian
philosophy. With Dionysius it enters the Catholic fold.
Side by side with the Neoplatonic mysticism of
St. Augustine and Dionysius runs another line of spiritual culture, hardly less
important for the development of the contemplative life. This takes its rise
among the Fathers of the Egyptian desert, whose heroic spirituality was a
contributory factor in St. Augustine's conversion. It finds beautiful
expression in the writings of St. Marcarius of Egypt (c. 295-386), the
disciple of St. Anthony and friend of St. Basil, and reaches the West through
the "Dialogues" of John Cassian (c. 350- ), one of the most important
documents for the history of Christian mysticism. The fruit of a seven-year
pilgrimage among the Egyptian monasteries, and many conversations on spiritual
themes with the monks, we find in these dialogues for the first time a
classified and realistic description of the successive degrees of contemplative
prayer, and their relation to the development of the spiritual life. Adopted by
St. Benedict as part of the regular spiritual food of his monks, they have had
a decisive influence on the cloistered mysticism of the Middle Ages. Their
sober and orderly doctrine, destined to be characteristic of the Roman Church,
received fresh emphasis in the works of St. Gregory the Great (540-604),
which also helped to form the souls of succeeding generations of
contemplatives.
We have therefore, at the opening of the Middle
Ages, two great streams of spiritual culture; the Benedictine, moderate and
practical, formed chiefly on Cassian and St. Gregory, and the Neoplatonic,
represented by Dionysius the Areopagite, and in a less exclusive form by St.
Augustine. The works of Dionysius were translated from Greek into Latin about
A.D. 850 by the Irish philosopher and theologian, John Scotus Erigena,
one of the scholars assembled at the court of Charlemagne: and this event marks
the beginning of a full tradition of mysticism in Western Europe. John the
Scot, many of whose own writings exhibit a strong mystical bias, is the only
name in this period which the history of mysticism can claim. We are on the
descending line of the "Dark Ages": and here the curve of
mysticism runs parallel with the curves of intellectual and artistic
activity.
The great current of medieval mysticism first
shows itself in the eleventh century, and chiefly in connection with the
Benedictine Order for the work of such monastic reformers as St. Romuald
(c. 950-1027) St. Peter Damian (1007-1072), and St. Bruno
(1032-1101), the founder of the Grande Chartreuse, was really the effort of
contemplative souls to establish an environment in which the mystical life
could be lived. Thus too we must regard at least a large proportion of the
hermits and solitaries who became so marked a feature in the religion of the
West. At this period mysticism was not sharply distinguished from the rest of
the religious complex, but was rather the realistic experience of the truths on
which religion rests. It spread mainly through personal instruction and
discipleship. Its literary monuments were few among the most important and
widely influential being the "Meditations" of St. Anselm (1033-1109),
which, disentangled by recent scholarship from the spurious material passing
under his name, are now seen to have been a chief channel of transmission for
the Augustinian mysticism which dominated the early Middle Ages. The general
religious revival of the twelfth century had its marked mystical aspect, and
produced four personalities of great historical importance: the Benedictines
St. Bernard of Clairvaux (1091-1153), St. Hildegarde of Bingen
(1098-1179), and Joachim of Flora (1132-1202); and the Scotch or Irish
Augustinian Richard of St. Victor (ob. c. 1173), whom Dante held
to be "in contemplation more than man." Richard's master and contemporary, the
scholastic philosopher Hugh (1097-1141) of the same Abbey of St. Victor
at Paris, is also generally reckoned amongst the mystics of thus period, but
with less reason; since contemplation occupies a small place in his theological
writings. In spite of the deep respect shown towards him by Aquinas and other
theologians, Hugh's influence on later mystical literature was slight. The
spirit of Richard and of St. Bernard, on the contrary, was destined to dominate
it for the next two hundred years. With them the literature of mediaeval
mysticism properly so called begins.
This literature Falls into two classes: the
personal and the didactic. Sometimes, as in a celebrated sermon of St. Bernard,
the two are combined; the teacher appealing to his own experience in
illustration of his theme. In the works of the Victorines the attitude is
didactic: one might almost say scientific. In them mysticism--that is to say,
the degrees of contemplation, the training and exercise of the spiritual
sense--takes its place as a recognized department of theology. It is in
Richard's favourite symbolism, "Benjamin," the beloved child of Rachel, emblem
of the Contemplative Life: and in his two chief works, "Benjamin Major" and
"Benjamin Minor," it is classified and described in all its branches. Though
mysticism was for Richard the "science of the heart" and he had little respect
for secular learning, yet his solid intellectuality did much to save the
medieval school from the perils of religious emotionalism. In his hands the
antique mystical tradition which flowed through Plotinus and the Areopagite,
was codified and transmitted to the mediaeval world. Like his
master, Hugh, he had the mediaeval passion for elaborate allegory, neat
arrangement, rigid classification, and significant numbers in things. As Dante
parcelled out Heaven, Purgatory, and Hell with mathematical precision, and
proved that Beatrice was herself a Nine, so these writers divide and subdivide
the stages of contemplation, the states of the soul, the degrees of Divine
Love: and perform terrible tours de force in the course of compelling
the ever-variable expressions of man's spiritual vitality to fall into orderly
and parallel series, conformable to the mystic numbers of Seven, Four, and
Three.
The influence of Richard of St. Victor, great as
it was, is exceeded by that of St. Bernard; the dominant spiritual personality
of the twelfth century. Bernard's career of ceaseless and varied activity
sufficiently disproves the "idleness" of the contemplative type. He continued
and informed with his own spirit the Benedictine tradition, and his writings
quickly took their place, with those of Richard of St. Victor, among the living
forces which conditioned the development of later mysticism. Both these mystics
exerted a capital influence on the formation of our national school of
mysticism in the fourteenth century. Translations and paraphrases of the
"Benjamin Major," "Benjamin Minor," and other works of Richard of St. Victor,
and of various tracts and epistles of St. Bernard, are constantly met with in
the MS. collections of mystical and theological literature written in England
in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. An early paraphrase of the
"Benjamin Minor," sometimes attributed to Richard Rolle, was probably made by
the anonymous author of "The Cloud of Unknowing," who was also responsible for
the first appearance of the Areopagite in English dress.
If mediaeval mysticism in the West develops
mainly under the sane and enduring influence of the Victorines and St. Bernard,
in Germany and Italy it appeared in a more startling form; seeking, in the
prophetic activities of St. Hildegarde of Bingen and the Abbot Joachim of
Flora, to influence the course of secular history. In St. Hildegarde and her
fellow-Benedictine St. Elizabeth of Shönau (1138-1165) we have the
first of that long line of women mystics--visionaries, prophetesses, and
political reformers--combining spiritual transcendence with great practical
ability, of whom St. Catherine of Siena is probably the greatest example.
Exalted by the strength of their spiritual intuitions, they emerged from an
obscure life to impose their wills, and their reading of events, upon the
world. From the point of view of Eternity, in whose light they lived, they
attacked the sins of their generation. St. Hildegarde, a woman of powerful
character, apparently possessed of abnormal psychic gifts, was driven by that
Living Light which was her inspiration to denounce the corruptions of Church
and State. In the inspired letters which she sent like firebrands over Europe,
we see German idealism and German practicality struggling together; the
unflinching description of abuses, the vast poetic vision by which they are
condemned. These qualities are seen again in the South German mystics of the
next century: the four Benedictine women of genius, who had their
home in the convent of Helfde. These are the Nun Gertrude (Abbess
1251-1291) and her sister St. Mechthild of Hackborn (ob. 1310),
with her sublime symbolic visions: then, the poet of the group, the exquisite
Mechthild of Magdeburg (1212-1299), who, first a béguine
at Magdeburg, where she wrote the greater part of "The Flowing Light of the
Godhead," came to Helfde in 1268; last the celebrated St. Gertrude the
Great (1256-1311). In these contemplatives the political spirit is less
marked than in St. Hildegarde: but religious and ethical activity takes its
place. St. Gertrude the Great is a characteristic Catholic visionary of the
feminine type: absorbed in her subjective experiences, her often beautiful and
significant dreams, her loving conversations with Christ and the Blessed
Virgin. Close to her in temperament is St. Mechthild of Hackborn; but her
attitude as a whole is more impersonal, more truly mystic. The great symbolic
visions in which her most spiritual perceptions are expressed are artistic
creations rather than psycho-sensorial hallucinations, and dwell little upon
the humanity of Christ, with which St. Gertrude is constantly occupied. The
terms in which Mechthild of Magdeburg--an educated and well-born woman, half
poet, half seer--describes her union with God are intensely individual, and
apparently owe more to the romantic poets of her time than to earlier religious
writers. The works of this Mechthild, early translated into Latin, were read by
Dante. Their influence is traceable in the "Paradiso"; and by some scholars she
is believed to be the Matilda of his Earthly Paradise, though others give this
position to her sister-mystic, St. Mechthild of Hackborn.
Modern scholarship tends more and more to see in
the strange personality of the Abbot Joachim of Flora, whom Dante placed among
the great contemplatives in the Heaven of the Sun, the chief influence in the
development of Italian mysticism. The true import of his prophecies, which
proclaimed in effect the substitution of mystical for institutional
Christianity, was only appreciated after his death. But their prestige grew
during the course of the thirteenth century; especially after the appearance of
the mendicant friars, who seemed to fulfil his prediction that the new era of
the Holy Spirit would be brought in about the year 1260 by two new Orders who
would live in poverty the spiritual life. From this time, Joachism found its
chief vehicle of expression through Franciscan mysticism of the more
revolutionary sort. Though there is no evidence that St. Francis of
Assisi (1182-1226) knew the prophecies of the "Eternal Gospel," he can
hardly have grown up without some knowledge of them, and also of the Cathari
and other semi-mystical heresies--many of them stressing the idea of
evangelical poverty--which were spreading through Italy from the north. But the
mystical genius which may have received food from these sources was itself
strikingly original; the spontaneous expression of a rare personality, a great
spiritual realist who admitted no rival to the absolute claims of the mystical
life of poverty and joy. St. Francis was untouched by monastic discipline, or
the writings of Dionysius or St. Bernard. His only literary influence was the
New Testament. With him, mysticism comes into the open air, seeks to transform
the stuff of daily life, speaks the vernacular, turns the songs of
the troubadours to the purposes of Divine love; yet remains completely loyal to
the Catholic Church. None who came after him succeeded in recapturing his
secret which was the secret of spiritual genius of the rarest type: but he left
his mark upon the history, art and literature of Western Europe, and the
influence of his spirit still lives.
In a general sense it is true to say that Italian
mysticism descends from St. Francis, and in its first period seems almost to be
the prerogative of his disciples; especially those of the "Spiritual" party who
strove to maintain his ideals in their purity. It is here that we find
Franciscan ardour and singlemindedness in alliance with apocalyptic notions
deriving from Joachist ideas. In Provence, a widespread mystical movement
coloured by Joachism was led by Hugues de Digne and his sister St.
Douceline (n. 1214); in whom we find a spirit which, like that of
Francis, could find the Divine through flowers and birds and simple natural
things. In Italy, nourished by the influence of such deeply mystical friars as
John of Parma (ob. 1288) and John of La Verna, this
Franciscan spirituality entered into conflict with the ecclesiastical politics
of the day; taking up that duty of denouncing the corruptions of the Church,
which has so often attracted the mystics. Here the typical figure is that of
Jacopone da Todi (1228-1306), the converted lawyer turned
mystical poet. On one hand deeply influenced by St. Augustine and Dionysius the
Areopagite, on the other the devoted exponent of the Founder's ideals, his
"spiritual songs" lift Franciscan mysticism to the heights of ecstatic rapture
and literary expression; whilst his savage castigations of the Papacy give him
a place among the great mediaeval satirists. Jacopone's poems have been shown
by Von Hügel to have had a formative influence on St. Catherine of Genoa;
and have probably affected many other mystics, not only in Italy but elsewhere,
for they quickly attained considerable circulation.
In his contemporary the Blessed Angela of
Foligno (1248-1309) who was converted from a sinful life to become a
tertiary hermit of the Franciscan Order we have a mystic of the first rank
whose visions and revelations place her in the same class as St. Catherine of
Genoa and St. Teresa. Known to her followers as the Mistress of Theologians,
and numbering among her disciples the brilliant and tempestuous "spiritual"
friar Ubertino da Casale, the lofty metaphysical element in Angela's mysticism
suggests the high level of spiritual culture achieved in Franciscan circles of
her time. By the sixteenth century her works, translated into the vernacular,
had taken their place amongst the classics of mysticism. In the seventeenth
they were largely used by St. François de Sales, Madame Guyon, and other
Catholic contemplatives. Seventeen years older than Dante, whose great genius
properly closes this line of spiritual descent, she is a link between the
thirteenth and fourteenth centuries in Italian mysticism.
We now approach the Golden Age of Mysticism: and
at the opening of that epoch, dominating it by their peculiar combination of
intellectual and spiritual power stand the figures of the "Seraphic and Angelic
Doctors," St. Bonaventura, the Franciscan (1221-1274), and
St. Thomas Aquinas, the Dominican (1226-1274). As with St. Augustine,
the intellectual greatness of St. Thomas has obscured his mystical side, whilst
St. Bonaventura, the apostle of a wise moderation, may easily appear to the
hurried reader the least mystical of the Franciscan mystics. Yet both were
contemplatives, and because of this were able to interpret to the medieval
world the great spiritual tradition of the past. Hence their immense influence
on the mystical schools of the fourteenth century. It is sometimes stated that
these schools derive mainly from St. Bonaventura, and represent an opposition
to scholastic theology; but as a matter of fact their greatest
personalities--in particular Dante and the German Dominicans--are soaked in the
spirit of Aquinas, and quote his authority at every turn.
In Europe the mystic curve is now approaching its
highest point. In the East that point has already been passed. Sufi, or
Mahommedan mysticism, appearing in the eighth century in the beautiful figure
of Rabi'a, the "Moslem St. Teresa" (717-801), and continued by the
martyr Al Hallaj (ob. 922), attains literary expression in the
eleventh in the "Confessions" of Al Ghazzali (1058-1111), and has its
classic period in the thirteenth in the works of the mystic poets `Attar
(c. 1140-1234), Sadi (1184-1263), and the saintly Jalalu `d Din
(1207-1273). Its tradition is continued in the fourteenth century by the rather
erotic mysticism of Hafiz (c. 1300-1388) and his successors, and in the
fifteenth by the poet Jámí (1414-1492).
Whilst Hafiz already strikes a note of decadence
for the mysticism of Islam, the year 1300 is for Western Europe a vital year in
the history of the spiritual life. Mystics of the first rank are appearing, or
about to appear. The Majorcan scholar-mystic Ramon Lull (ob.
1315) is drawing to the end of his long life. In Italy Dante
(1265-1321) is forcing human language to express one of the most sublime
visions of the Absolute which has ever been crystallized into speech. He
inherits and fuses into one that loving and artistic reading of reality which
was the heart of Franciscan mysticism, and that other ordered vision of the
transcendental world which the Dominicans through Aquinas poured into the
stream of European thought. For the one the spiritual world was all love: for
the other all law. For Dante it was both. In the "Paradiso" his stupendous
genius apprehends and shows to us a Beatific Vision in which the symbolic
systems of all great mystics and many whom the world does not call mystics--of
Dionysius, Richard, St. Bernard, Mechthild, Aquinas, and countless others--are
included and explained.
The moment in which the "Commedia" was being
written coincides with the awakening of mystical activity in Germany and
Flanders. Between the years 1280 and 1309 was produced, probably in the Liege
district and under Franciscan influence, the curious anonymous work which is
now only known to us in Latin and English translations--"The Mirror of
Simple Souls." This long treatise, clearly influenced by Dionysius, the
Victorines, and the twelfth-century tract known as the "Letter to the Brethren
of Mons Dei," is a piece of mystical literature of an advanced kind, often
fringing the borders of orthodoxy and looking forward to the
speculative Flemish mysticism of the fourteenth century. Its writer was
probably contemporary with the founder of this school; the great Dominican
scholar Meister Eckhart (1260-1327), who resembled Dante in his
combination of mystical insight with intense intellectual power, and laid the
foundations at once of German philosophy and German mysticism. These two giants
stand side by side at the opening of the century; perfect representatives of
the Teutonic and Latin instinct for transcendental reality.
Eckhart, though only a few years younger than St.
Gertrude the Great, seems to belong to a different world. His commanding
personality, his genius for the supra-sensible nourished by the works of
Dionysius and Erigena, moulded and inspired all whom it came near. The German
and Flemish mystics of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, differing much
in temperament from their master and from each other, have yet something in
common: something which is shared by no other school. This something is derived
from Eckhart; for all have passed under his hand, being either his immediate
disciples, or the friends or pupils of his disciples. Eckhart's doctrine is
chiefly known to us by reports of his vernacular sermons delivered at
Strassburg; then the religious centre of Germany. In these we see him as a
teaching mystic full of pastoral zeal, but demanding a high level both of
intellect and spirituality in those he addressed. Towards the end of his life
he fell into disgrace. A number of propositions extracted from his writings,
and representing his more extreme views, were condemned by the Church as
savouring of pantheism and other heresies: and certainly the violence and
daring of his language laid him open to misconstruction. In his efforts to
speak of the unspeakable he was constantly betrayed into expressions which were
bound to seem paradoxical and exaggerated to other men. Eckhart's influence,
however, was little hurt by ecclesiastical condemnation. His pupils, though
they remained loyal Catholics, contrived also to be loyal disciples. To the end
of their lives their teaching was coloured--often inspired--by the doctrines of
the great, if heretical, scholar whose memory they venerated as that of a
saint.
The contrast in type between Eckhart and his two
most famous disciples is an interesting one. All three were Dominican friars;
all were devout followers of St. Augustine, the Areopagite, St. Bernard, and
Aquinas; all had been trained in the schools of Cologne, where Albert the Great
and St. Thomas had taught, and where their powerful influence still lived. The
mysticism of Eckhart, so far as he allows us to see it in his sermons and
fragmentary writings, is objective--one might almost say dogmatic. He describes
with an air of almost terrible certainty and intimacy, not that which he has
felt, but the place or plane of being he has known--"the desert of the Godhead
were no one is at home." He is a great scholar, a natural metaphysician
passionately condensed with the quest of Absolute Truth.
Of his two pupils, John Tauler (c.
1300-1361), friar-preacher of Strassburg, was a born missionary: a man who
combined with great theological learning and mystical genius of a high order an
overwhelming zeal for souls. He laboured incessantly to awaken men
to a sense of their transcendental heritage. Without the hard intellectualism
occasionally noticeable in Eckhart, or the tendency to introspection and the
excessive artistic sensibility of Suso, Tauler is the most virile of the German
mystics. The breadth of his humanity is only equalled by the depth of his
spirituality. His sermons--his only authentic works--are trumpet-calls to
heroic action upon spiritual levels. They influenced many later mystics,
especially St. Teresa and St. John of the Cross. Tauler is not a subjective
writer: only by implication can we assure ourselves that he speaks from
personal experience. He has sometimes, though unfairly, been described as a
precursor of the Reformation. Such a claim could only be made by those who look
upon all pure Christianity as a form of Protestant heresy. He attacked, like
St. Hildegarde, St. Catherine of Siena, and many others, the ecclesiastical
corruption of his period: but his writings, if read in unexpurgated editions,
prove him to have been a fervent and orthodox Catholic.
Tauler was one of the leading spirits in the
great informal society of the Friends of God, which sprang into being in
Strassburg, spread through the Rhenish province and beyond to Switzerland and
Bavaria, and worked in this moment of religious decadence for the spiritual
regeneration of the people. In a spirit of fierce enthusiasm and wholehearted
devotion, the Friends of God set themselves to the mystic life as the only life
worthy of the name. A great outburst of transcendental activity took place:
many visions and ecstasies were reported: amazing conversions occurred. The
movement had many features in common with that of the Quakers; except that it
took place within, instead of without, the official Church, and was partly
directed against the doctrines of the Brethren of the Free Spirit and other
heretical sects. With it was connected the third of the trio of great German
Dominican mystics, the Blessed Henry Suso (c. 1295-1365), a natural
recluse and ascetic, and a visionary of the most exuberant Catholic type. To
Suso, subjective, romantic, deeply interested in his own soul and his personal
relation with God, mysticism was not so much a doctrine to be imparted to other
men as an intimate personal adventure. Though a trained philosopher and
theologian, and a devoted follower of Eckhart, his autobiography--a human
document far more detailed and ingenuous than St. Teresa's more celebrated
"Life"--is mainly the record of his griefs and joys, his pains, visions,
ecstasies, and miseries. Even his mystical treatises are in dialogue form, as
if he could hardly get away from the personal and dramatic aspect of the
spiritual life.
Around these three--Eckhart, Tauler, Suso--are
gathered other and more shadowy personalities: members of this mystical society
of the Friends of God, bound to the heroic attempt to bring life--the terribly
corrupt and disordered religious life of the fourteenth century--back into
relation with spiritual reality, to initiate their neighbours into the
atmosphere of God. From one of these nameless members comes the literary jewel
of the movement: the beautiful little treatise called the "Theologia
Germanica," or "Book of the Perfect Life," probably written in Frankfort
about the year 1350 by a priest of the Teutonic Order. One of the
most successful of many attempts to make mystic principles available for common
men, this book was greatly loved by Luther, who published an incomplete edition
in 1518. Other Friends of God are now only known to us as the authors of
letters, descriptions of conversions, visions, and spiritual
adventures--literature which the movement produced in enormous quantities. No
part of the history of mysticism has been more changed by recent research than
that of the Rhenish school: and the work is still but partly done. At present
we can only record the principal names which we find connected with the
mystical propaganda of the Friends of God. These are first the nuns Margaret
Ebner (1291-1351) and her sister Christina, important personages in
the movement upon whose historicity no doubts have been cast. Margaret appears
to have been a psychic as well as a mystic: and to have possessed, like Madame
Guyon, telepathic and clairvoyant powers. Next the rather shadowy pair of
laymen, Henry of Nordlingen and Nicolas of Basle. Lastly the
puzzling figure of Rulman Merswin (c. 1310-1382), author of the series
of apocalyptic visions called The Book of the Nine Rocks"; whose story of his
conversion and mystic life, whether it be regarded as fact or "tendency
literature," is a psychological document of the first rank.
In immediate dependence on the German school, and
like it drawing its intellectual vigour from the genius of Eckhart, is the
mysticism of Flanders: best known to us in the work of its most sublime
representative, the Blessed John Ruysbroeck (1293-1381), one of the
greatest mystics whom the world has yet known. In Ruysbroeck's works the
metaphysical and personal aspects of mystical truth are fused and attain their
highest expression. Intellectually indebted to St. Augustine, Richard of St.
Victor, and Eckhart, his value lies in the fact that the Eckhartian philosophy
was merely the medium by which he expressed the results of profound experience.
In his early years a priest in Brussels, in old age a recluse in the forest of
Soignes, Ruysbroeck's influence on his own generation was great. Through his
disciple Gerard Groot (1340-1384), founder of the Brotherhood of the
Common Life, it formed the inspiration of the religious movement of the New
Devotion; which carried over into the next century the spirit of the great
mediaeval mystics. The mystical writings of Henry de Mande (c.
1360-1415), the "Ruysbroeck of the North," the beautiful and deeply Platonic
"Fiery Soliloquy with God" of Gerlac Petersen (1378-1411), and above all
the "Imitation of Christ" of his friend Thomas à Kempis
(1380-1471), in which some of Gerard Groot's meditations may be enshrined, are
the chief channels through which this mystical current passed. In the next
century the Franciscan Henry de Herp or Harphius (ob. 1477) and
two greater personalities--the learned and holy Platonist, Cardinal Nicolas
of Cusa (1401-1464), and his friend the theologian and contemplative
Denis the Carthusian (1402-1471), one of the great religious figures of
the fifteenth century--drew their inspiration from Ruysbroeck. Denis translated
the whole of his works into Latin; and calls him "another Dionysius" but "clear
where the Areopagite is obscure." It was mainly through the voluminous writings
of Denis, widely read during succeeding centuries, that the
doctrine of the mediaeval mystics was carried over to the Renaissance world.
Ruysbroeck's works, with those of Suso, appear in English MSS. early in the
fifteenth century, taking their place by the side of St. Bernard, St.
Bonaventura, and the great English mystic Richard Rolle. The influence of his
genius has also been detected in the mystical literature of Spain.
English mysticism seems to have its roots in the
religious revival which arose during Stephen's reign. It was then, and
throughout its course, closely linked with the solitary life. Its earnest
literary monument, the "Ancren Riwle," was written early in the twelfth century
for the use of three anchoresses. So too the "Meditations" of St. Aldred
(Abbot of Rievaulx 1146-1166), and the Rule he wrote for his anchoress sister,
presuppose the desire for the mystical life. But the first English mystic we
can name with certainty is Margery Kempe (probably writing c. 1290), the
anchoress of Lynn. Even so, we know nothing of this woman's life; and only a
fragment of her "Contemplations" has survived. It is with the next name,
Richard Rolle of Hampole (c. 1300-1349), that the short but brilliant
procession of English mystics begins. Rolle, educated at Oxford and perhaps at
Paris, and widely read in theology, became a hermit in order to live in
perfection that mystic life of "Heat, Sweetness, and Song," to which he felt
himself to be called. Richard of St. Victor, St. Bernard, and St. Bonaventura
are the authors who have influenced him most; but he remains, in spite of this,
one of the most individual of all writers on mysticism. A voluminous author,
his chief works are still in MS., and he seems to have combined the careers of
writer and wandering preacher with that of recluse. He laid claim to direct
inspiration, was outspoken in his criticisms of religious and secular life, and
in the next generation the Lollards were found to appeal to his authority.
Rolle already shows the practical temper characteristic of the English school.
His interest was not philosophy, but spiritual life; and especially his own
experience of it. There is a touch of Franciscan poetry in his descriptions of
his communion with Divine Love, and the "heavenly song" in which it was
expressed, of Franciscan ardour in his zeal for souls. His works greatly
influenced succeeding English mystics.
He was followed in the second half of the
fourteenth century by the unknown author of "The Cloud of Unknowing" and
its companion treatises, and by the gracious spirit of Walter Hilton
(ob. 1396). With "The Cloud of Unknowing," the spirit of Dionysius first
appears in English literature. It is the work of an advanced contemplative,
deeply influenced by the Areopagite and the Victorines, who was also an acute
psychologist. From the hand that wrote it came the first English translation of
the "Theologia Mystica," "Dionise Hid Divinite": a work which says an old
writer, "ran across England at deere rates," so ready was the religious
consciousness of the time for the reception of mystical truth.
Hilton, though also influenced by Dionysius and
Richard of St. Victor, addresses a wider audience. He is pre-eminently a
spiritual director, the practical teacher of interior ways, not a
metaphysician; and his great work "The Scale of Perfection" quickly took rank
among the classics of the spiritual life. The moment of his death
coincides with the completion of the most beautiful of all English mystical
works, the "Revelations of Love" of the anchoress Julian of Norwich
(1343-died after 1413), "theodidacta, profunda,
ecstatica," whose unique personality closes and crowns the history of
English mediaeval mysticism. In her the best gifts of Rolle and Hilton are
transmuted by a "genius for the infinite" of a peculiarly beautiful and
individual type. She was a seer, a lover, and a poet. Though considerable
theological knowledge underlies her teaching, it is in essence the result of a
direct and personal vision of singular intensity.
Already before the completion of Julian's
revelations two other women of genius, the royal prophetess and founder St.
Bridget of Sweden (1303-1373) and St. Catherine of Siena
(1347-1380), had lived and died. St. Bridget, or Birgitta, a mystic and
visionary of the Hildegardian type, believed herself called to end the exile of
the Papacy and bring peace to the Church. Four months after her death, St.
Catherine--then aged 26--took up her unfinished work. The true successor of
Dante as a revealer of Reality, and next to St. Francis the greatest of Italian
mystics, Catherine exhibits the Unitive Life in its richest, most perfect form.
She was a great active and a great ecstatic: at once politician, teacher, and
contemplative, holding a steady balance between the inner and the outer life.
Well named "the mother of thousands of souls," with little education she yet
contrived, in a short career dogged by persistent ill-health, to change the
course of history, rejuvenate religion, and compose, in her "Divine Dialogue,"
one of the jewels of Italian religious literature.
With the first half of the fifteenth century it
is plain that the mystic curve droops downwards. At its opening we find the
influential figure of the Chancellor Gerson (1363-1429) at once a mystic
in his own right and a keen and impartial critic of extravagant mystical
teachings and phenomena. But the great period is over: the new life of the
Renaissance, already striving in other spheres of activity, has hardly touched
the spiritual plane. A transient revival of Franciscan spirituality is
associated with the work of three reforming mystics; the energetic French
visionary St. Colette of Corbie (1381-1447), her Italian disciple St.
Bernardino of Siena (1380-1444), and the ecstatic Clarisse, St.
Catherine of Bologna (1413-1463). Contemporary with this group are the
careers of two strongly contrasted woman-mystics: St. Joan of Arc
(1412-1431), and the suffering Flemish visionary St. Lydwine of Schiedam
(1380-1432).
With the second half of the century the scene
shifts to Italy, where a spiritual genius of the first rank appeared in St.
Catherine of Genoa (1447-1510). She, like her namesake of Siena, was at
once an eager lover and an indomitable doer. More, she was a constructive
mystic, a profound thinker as well as an ecstatic: an original teacher, a busy
and practical philanthropist. Her influence lived on, and is seen in the next
generation in the fine, well-balanced nature of another contemplative: the
Venerable Battista Vernazza (1497-1587), her goddaughter and the child
of one of her most loyal friends. Catherine of Genoa stands alone
in her day as an example of the sane and vigorous mystic life. Her
contemporaries were for the most part visionaries of the more ordinary female
type, such as Osanna Andreasi of Mantua (1449-1505), Columba
Rieti (c. 1430-1501) and her disciple Lucia of Narni. They seem to
represent the slow extinction of the spirit which burned so bright in St.
Catherine of Siena.
That spirit reappears in the sixteenth century in
Flanders in the works of the Benedictine Abbot Blosius (1506-1565); and,
far more conspicuously, in Spain, a country hardly touched by the outburst of
mystical life which elsewhere closed the medieval period. Spanish mysticism
first appears in close connection with the religious orders: in the Franciscans
Francisco de Osuna (ob. c. 1540), whose manual of contemplative
prayer influenced the development of St. Teresa, and St. Peter of
Alcantara (1499-1562), her friend and adviser; in the Dominican Luis de
Granada (1504-1588) and the Augustinian Luis de Leon (1528-1591). It
attains definite and characteristic expression in the life and personality of
St. Ignatius Loyola (1491-1556), the great founder of the Society of
Jesus. The concrete nature of St. Ignatius' work, and especially its later
developments, has blinded historians to the fact that he was a true mystic, own
brother to such great actives as St. Teresa and George Fox, actuated by the
same vision of reality, passing through the same stages of psychological
growth. His spiritual sons greatly influenced the inner life of the great
Carmelite, St. Teresa (1515-1582).
Like St. Catherine of Siena, these mystics--and
to them we must add St. Teresa's greatest disciple, the poet and contemplative
St. John of the Cross (1542-1591)--seem to have arisen in direct
response to the need created by the corrupt or disordered religious life of
their time. They were the "saints of the counter-Reformation"; and, in a period
of ecclesiastical chaos, flung the weight of their genius and their sanctity
into the orthodox Catholic scale. Whilst St. Ignatius organized a body of
spiritual soldiery, who should attack heresy and defend the Church, St. Teresa,
working against heavy odds, infused new vitality into a great religious order
and restored it to its duty of direct communion with the transcendental world.
In this she was helped by St. John of the Cross; who, a psychologist and
philosopher as well as a great mystic, performed the necessary function of
bringing the personal experience of the Spanish school back again into touch
with the main stream of mystic tradition. All three, practical organizers and
profound contemplatives, exhibit in its splendour the dual character of the
mystic life. They left behind them in their literary works an abiding influence
which has guided the footsteps and explained the discoveries of succeeding
generations of adventurers in the transcendental world. The true spiritual
children of these mystics are to be found, not in their own country, where the
religious life which they had lifted to transcendent levels degenerated when
their overmastering influence was withdrawn, but amongst the innumerable
contemplative souls of succeeding generations who have fallen under the spell
of the "Spiritual Exercises," the "Interior Castle," or the "Dark Night of the
Soul."
The Divine fire lit by the great Carmelites of
Spain is next seen in Italy, in the lives of the Dominican nun St. Catherine
dei Ricci (1522-1590) and the Florentine Carmelite St. Maria Maddelena
dei Pazzi (1566-1607), the author of voluminous literary works. It appears
in the New World in the beautiful figure of St. Rose of Lima
(1586-1617), the Peruvian nun; and at the same moment, under a very different
aspect, in Protestant Germany, in the person of one of the giants of mysticism,
the "inspired shoemaker" Jacob Boehme (1575-1624).
Boehme, one of the most astonishing cases in
history of a natural genius for the transcendent, has left his mark upon German
philosophy as well as upon the history of mysticism. William Law, Blake, and
Saint-Martin are amongst those who have sat at his feet. The great sweep of
Boehme's vision includes both Man and the Universe: the nature of God and of
the Soul. In him we find again that old doctrine of Rebirth which the earlier
German mystics had loved. Were it not for the difficult symbolism in which his
vision is expressed, his influence would be far greater than it is. He remains
one of those cloud-wrapped immortals who must be rediscovered and reinterpreted
by the adventurers of every age.
The seventeenth century rivals the fourteenth in
the richness and variety of its mystical life. Two main currents are to be
detected in it: dividing between them the two main aspects of man's communion
with the Absolute. One, symbolic, constructive, activistic, bound up with the
ideas of regeneration, and often using the language of the alchemists sets out
from the Teutonic genius of Boehme. It achieves its successes outside the
Catholic Church, and chiefly in Germany and England, where by 1650 his works
were widely known. In its decadent forms it runs to the occult: to alchemy,
Rosicrucianism, apocalyptic prophecy, and other aberrations of the spiritual
sense. The other current arises within the Catholic Church, and in close touch
with the great tradition of Christian mysticism. It achieves fullest expansion
in France, and tends to emphasize the personal and intimate side of
contemplation: encouraging passive receptivity and producing in its exaggerated
forms the aberrations of the Quietists.
In the seventeenth century England was peculiarly
rich, if not in great mystics, at any rate in mystically minded men, seekers
after Reality. Mysticism, it seems, was in the air; broke out under many
disguises and affected many forms of life. It produced in George Fox
(1624-1690), the founder of the Quakers, a "great active" of the first rank,
entirely unaffected by tradition, and in the Quaker movement itself an outbreak
of genuine mysticism which is only comparable to the fourteenth-century
movement of the Friends of God.
We meet in Fox that overwhelming sense of direct
relationship with God, that consciousness of the transcendent characteristic of
the mystic; and Quaker spirituality, in spite of its marked aversion to
institutional religion, has much in common not only with those Continental
Quietists who are its most obvious spiritual affinities, but also with the
doctrine of the Catholic contemplatives. Mysticism crops up frequently in the
writings of the school; and finds expression in the first generation in the works of Isaac Penington (1616-1679) and in the second in
the Journal of the heroic American Friend John Woolman (1720-1772).
At the opposite end of the theological scale, the
seventeenth century gives us a group of English mystics of the
Catholic type, closely related to the contemporary French school. Of these, one
of the most individual is the young Benedictine nun Gertrude More
(1606-1633), who carries on that tradition of the communion of love
which flows from St. Augustine through St. Bernard and Thomas à Kempis,
and is the very heart of Catholic mysticism. In the writings of her director,
and the preserver of her works, the Venerable Augustine Baker
(1575-1641)--one of the most lucid and orderly of guides to the contemplative
life--we see what were still the formative influences in the environment where
her mystical powers were trained. Richard of St. Victor, Hilton, and "The Cloud
of Unknowing"; Angela of Foligno; Tauler, Suso, Ruysbroeck; St. Teresa and St.
John of the Cross; these are the authorities to whom Augustine Baker most
constantly appeals, and through these, as we know, the family tree of the
mystics goes back to the Neoplatonists and the first founders of the Church.
Outside that Church, the twins Thomas
Vaughan the spiritual alchemist and Henry Vaughan, Silurist, the
mystical poet (1622-1695) show the reaction of two very different temperaments
upon the transcendental life. Again, the group of "Cambridge Platonists,"
Henry More (1614-1687), John Smith (1618-1652), Benjamin
Whichcote (1609-1683), Peter Sterry (c. 1614-1672), and John
Norris (1657-1711) developed and preached a philosophy deeply tinged with
mysticism; and Thomas Traherne (c. 1637-1674) gave poetic expression to
the Platonic vision of life. In Bishop Hall (1574-1656) the same spirit
takes a devotional form. Finally, the Rosicrucians, symbolists, and other
spiritually minded occultists--above all the extraordinary sect of
Philadelphians, ruled by Dr. Pordage (1608-1698) and the prophetess
Jane Lead (1623-1704)--exhibit mysticism in its least balanced aspect
mingled with mediumistic phenomena, wild symbolic visions, and apocalyptic
prophecies. The influence of these Philadelphians, who were themselves strongly
affected by Boehme's works, lingered for a century, appearing again in
Saint-Martin the "Unknown Philosopher."
The Catholic mysticism of this period is best
seen in France, where the intellectual and social expansion of the Grande
Siècle had also its spiritual side. Over against the brilliant worldly
life of seventeenth-century Paris and the slackness and even corruption of much
organized religion there sprang up something like a cult of the inner life.
This mystical renaissance seems to have originated in the work of an English
Capuchin friar, William Fitch, in religion Benedict Canfield
(1520-1611), who settled in Paris in old age and there became a centre of
spiritual influence. Among his pupils were Madame Acarie (1566-1618) and
Pierre de Bérulle (1575-1629), and through them his teaching on
contemplation affected all the great religious personalities of the period. The
house of Madame Acarie--a woman equally remarkable for spiritual genius and
practical ability--became the gathering-point of a growing mystical enthusiasm,
which also expressed itself in a vigorous movement of reform
within the Church. Bérulle was one of the founders of the Oratory.
Madame Acarie, known as the "conscience of Paris," visited the relaxed convents
and persuaded them to a more strict and holy life. Largely by her
instrumentality, the first houses of reformed Carmelites were established in
France in 1604, nuns being brought to direct them from St. Teresa's Spanish
convents, and French mysticism owes much to this direct contact with the
Teresian school. Madame Acarie and her three daughters all became Carmelite
nuns; and it was from the Dijon Carmelites that St. Jeanne Françoise
de Chantal (1572-1641) received her training in contemplation. Her
spiritual father, and co-founder of the Order of the Visitation, St.
François de Sales (1567-1622), had also been in youth a member of
Madame Acarie's circle. He shows at its best the peculiar talent of the French
school for the detailed and individual direction of souls. Outside this
cultured and aristocratic group two great and pure mystics arise from humbler
social levels. First the intrepid Ursuline nun Marie de l'Incarnation
(1599-1672), the pioneer of education in the New World, in whom we find again
St. Teresa's twin gifts for high contemplation and practical initiative.
Secondly the Carmelite friar Brother Lawrence (1611-1691), who shows the
passive tendency of French mysticism in its most sane, well-balanced form. He
was a humble empiricist, laying claim to no special gifts: a striking contrast
to his contemporary, the brilliant and unhappy genius Pascal
(1623-1662), who fought his way through many psychic storms to the vision of
the Absolute.
The genuine French and Flemish mysticism of this
period, greatly preoccupied with the doctrines of self-naughting and passivity,
constantly approached the frontiers of Quietism. The three great Capuchin
teachers of contemplation, the Flemings Constantine Barbançon
(1581-1632) and John Evangelist of Barluke (1588-1635), and the English
Benedict Canfield, were not entirely beyond suspicion in this regard; as their
careful language, and the scrutiny to which they were subjected by contemporary
authority, clearly shows. The line between the true and false doctrine was a
fine one, as we see in the historic controversy between Bossuet and Fenelon;
and the perilous absurdities of the Quietist writers often tempted the orthodox
to draw it in the wrong place.
The earliest in date and most exaggerated in type
of these true Quietists is the Franco-Flemish Antoinette Bourignan
(1616-1680): a strong-willed and wrong-headed woman who, having renounced the
world with Franciscan thoroughness, founded a sect, endured considerable
persecutions, and made a great stir in the religious life of her time. An even
greater uproar resulted from the doctrinal excesses of the devout Spanish
priest Miguel de Molinos (1640-1697); whose extreme teachings were
condemned by the Church, and for a time brought the whole principle of passive
contemplation into disrepute. Quietism, at bottom, was the unbalanced
expression of that need which produced the contemporary Quaker movement in
England: a need for personal contact with spiritual realities, evoked by the
formal and unsatisfying quality of the official religion of the time.
Unfortunately the great Quietists were not great mystics. Hence
their propaganda, in which the principle of passivity--divorced from, and
opposed to, all spiritual action--was pressed to its logical conclusion,
resulted in a doctrine fatal not only to all organized religion but to the
healthy development of the inner life.
Madame Guyon (1648-1717), the contemporary
of Molinos, is usually quoted as a typical Quietist. She is an example of the
unfortunate results of an alliance of mystical tendencies with a feeble surface
intelligence. Had she possessed the robust common sense so often found in the
great contemplatives, her temperamental inclination to passivity would have
been checked, and she would hardly have made use of the exaggerated expressions
which brought about the official condemnation of her works. In spite of the
brilliant championship of Fenelon, and the fact that much of her writing merely
reproduces orthodox teaching on contemplative prayer in an inferior form, she
was involved in the general condemnation of "passive orison" which the
aberrations of the extreme Quietists had called forth.
The end of the seventeenth century saw a great
outburst of popular Quietism, some within and some without the official Church.
Well within the frontiers of orthodoxy, and exhibiting the doctrine of
passivity in its noblest form, was the Jesuit J. P. de Caussade (still
living 1739). Among those who over-stepped the boundary--though all the
Quietists appealed to the general tradition of mysticism in support of their
one-sided doctrine--were Malaval, whose "Théologie Mystique"
contains some beautiful French translations from St. Teresa, and Peter
Poiret (1646-1719), once a Protestant pastor, then the devoted disciple of
Antoinette Bourignan. Later generations owe much to the enthusiasm and industry
of Poiret, whose belief in spiritual quiescence was combined with great
literary activity. He rescued and edited all Madame Guyon's writings; and has
left us, in his "Bibliotheca Mysticorum," the memorial of many lost works on
mysticism. From this unique bibliography we can see how "orthodox" was the food
which nourished even the most extreme of the Quietists: how thoroughly they
believed themselves to represent not a new doctrine, but the true tradition of
Christian mysticism.
With the close of the seventeenth century, the
Quietist movement faded away. The beginning of the eighteenth sees the triumph
of that other stream of spiritual vitality which arose outside the Catholic
Church and flowed from the great personality of Jacob Boehme. If the idea of
surrender be the mainspring of Quietism, the complementary idea of rebirth is
the mainspring of this school. In Germany, Boehme's works had been collected
and published by an obscure mystic, John Gichtel (1638-1710); whose life
and letters constantly betray his influence. In England, where that influence
had been a living force from the middle of the seventeenth century, when
Boehme's writings first became known, the Anglo-German Dionysius Andreas
Freher was writing between 1699 and 1720. In the early years of the
eighteenth century, Freher was followed by William Law (1686-1761), the
Nonjuror: a brilliant stylist, and one of the most profound of English
religious writers. Law, who was converted by the reading of
Boehme's works from the narrow Christianity to which he gave classic expression
in the "Serious Call" to a wide and philosophic mysticism, gave, in a series of
writings which burn with mystic passion, a new interpretation and an abiding
place in English literature to the "inspired shoemaker's" mighty vision of Man
and the Universe.
The latter part of a century which clearly
represents the steep downward trend of the mystic curve gives us three strange
personalities; all of whom have passed through Boehme's school, and have placed
themselves in opposition to the ecclesiasticism of their day. In Germany,
Eckartshausen (1752-1803), in "The Cloud upon the Sanctuary" and other
works, continued upon individual lines that tradition of esoteric and mystical
Christianity, and of rebirth as the price of man's entrance into Reality, which
found its best and sanest interpreter in William Law. In France the troubled
spirit of the transcendentalist Saint-Martin (1743-1803), the "Unknown
Philosopher," was deeply affected in his passage from a merely occult to a
mystical philosophy by the reading of Boehme and Eckartshausen, and also by the
works of the English "Philadelphians," Dr. Pordage and Jane Lead, who had long
sunk to oblivion in their native land. In England, William Blake, poet,
painter, visionary, and prophet (1757-1827), shines like a solitary star in the
uncongenial atmosphere of the Georgian age.
The career of Blake provides us with a rare
instance of mystical genius, forcing not only rhythm and words, but also colour
and form to express its vision of truth. So individual in his case was this
vision, so strange the elements from which his symbolic reconstructions were
built up, that he failed in the attempt to convey it to other men. Neither in
his prophetic books nor in his beautiful mystical paintings does he contrive to
transmit more than great and stimulating suggestions of "things seen" in some
higher and more valid state of consciousness. Whilst his visionary symbolism
derives to a large extent from Swedenborg, whose works were the great influence
of his youth, Blake has learned much from Boehme, and probably from his English
interpreters. Almost alone amongst English Protestant mystics, he has also
received and assimilated the Catholic tradition of the personal and inward
communion of love. In his great vision of "Jerusalem," St. Teresa and Madame
Guyon are amongst the "gentle souls" whom he sees guarding that Four-fold Gate
which opens towards Beulah--the gate of the contemplative life--and guiding the
great "Wine-press of Love" whence mankind, at the hands of its mystics, has
received, in every age, the Wine of Life.
Bibliography